In a previous blog post of mine, I talked about how,
sometimes, I feel that a lot of the things that are said about books in
English classes are just reading way too much into the book and what the
author intended. I recently had an interesting conversation about this
with some classmates and some non-classmates, specifically dealing with
A Lesson Before Dying and especially Paul.
First
of all, allow me to say that much of what I usually say about the
supposed "classics" we read in English classes does not apply here. The
reason for this is simple: A Lesson Before Dying is by far the best book I have ever read for any class in school, and is quite high on the list of my all-time favorite books.
With that out of the way, the conversation between myself and three
other students (who shall remain unnamed) was a debate of sorts. The
two sides mainly argued were whether the parallels between the deputy
sheriff Paul and the apostle Paul were superficial coincidences, or
intended and deliberately included by Gaines.
On the one
hand, it is likely possible to take any fictional character and find
however many connections to historical figures, biblical figures, or
whatever else. It could just be a coincidence that these parallels
appear, and a character is just a character, nothing more. I often
complain of too much being read into a story, finding deep and hidden
meanings where, really, none exist. Of course, I often have this
complaint of books that I read for English classes. I wouldn't like to
think that just because I like a book I start seeing connections and
metaphors where there really shouldn't be any.
However,
in this case I really do think that the connections between the deputy
sheriff Paul and the apostle Paul are real and significant. I think
that it would be far too much of a coincidence for an enemy of the main
character who is then more or less "converted," and who holds a position
of power before and after his conversion to also be named Paul, just as
Jesus's enemy and then ally in the Bible. In this case, I think it
would be far stranger if, in fact, the characters had nothing to do with
each other, as that would be a genuinely scary amount of coincidence.
In addition, I think that it is important to note just how important
Paul's "conversion" is. This is someone who, in all likelihood, could
be the sheriff of Bayonne at some point in the future, and this series
of events has destroyed much of his prejudice towards the blacks in his
community. Just as Paul became instrumental to the spread of
Christianity after Jesus's death, so Paul could become a huge part of
progress in his community in the future.
Hahah I agree with the sometimes reading to much into things, but I guess that's just what lets different people have different interpretations of stuff. You can read it however it's written, or read into it in several different ways. But I also agree that the Paul comparison is definitely intentional. Paul is kind of a representative figure of the sheriffs (they all have the same mindset) but he's able to alter his views after the Jefferson situation and I think it's a big step to turn. And he will later be able to have a larger impact on the community as a whole, so I do see the connection made there and I also think it was intended.
ReplyDeleteThis definitely resonates with me. The message you get from a book is up to the individual to decide but I agree that Paul's name isn't a coincidence. He goes from being part of the cycle that perpetuates racism to learning to accept the black people he comes in contact with and even offers his friendship to them, thus becoming part of effort to break the system.
ReplyDeleteI agree with you that there is too much similarity between the two for this to just simply be a coincidence. The sheriff Paul changes throughout the book similarly to how Paul from the Bible did, and like you said, I believe that he will play a similar role in the community now after the death of Jefferson. This connection also brings up the fact that Paul might be a more significant character than what it may seem like had this connection not been drawn. We could have easily overlooked Paul as another minor character, but now we can predict that Paul might play an important role in continuing what Jefferson started.
ReplyDelete