Friday, December 16, 2016

A Mile In Ma's Shoes

          In class, we have talked a lot about interpreting what we see of the real world as described by Jack.  His views and style of description are certainly not normal, and sometimes leave us guessing as to what could really be going on.  The core disconnect here is, I think, that Jack is essentially unable to put himself in the perspective of others.  This is, perhaps, something that every five-year-old is prone to, but Jack's specific situation likely exacerbates it.
          There are many examples of Jack simply not being able to empathize with others.  Much of the time, he is simply unable to understand the actions and reactions of others--for instance, his frequent bafflement at the rules of "politeness" and "manners" in the real world.  In some cases, though it sounds rather harsh, I feel that if Jack were simply to put some thought into things, he would understand them much better.  It is, however, quite likely that a large component of Jack's lack of empathy could be due to simply lacking the correct life experiences to be able to relate to others on any meaningful level.  From looking at this idea in a vacuum, it would seem that the person Jack would most be able to relate to would be Ma.  And, to an extent, this is true.  But there are still core disconnects between their perspectives that Jack makes little effort to bridge, even though I feel that he could.
          When Jack expresses a desire to revisit Room towards the end of the book, his insistence really hurts Ma.  At one point she says something along the lines of "If you would just think of someone besides yourself for one moment..."  And that is, I think, one of the core problems that Jack has.  He is very selfish.  I suppose that most children are like this to one extent or another, but even if they are it just goes to show how being raised in a completely different environment results in the same attitude, perhaps indicating a core aspect of human nature.
          Ma does not understand why Jack would want to go back to Room, even though it makes perfect sense from Jack's perspective.  Jack does not understand why Ma doesn't want to go back to Room.  Of the two perspectives, Ma's is the only one that is reasonable and based on an accurate assessment of the world--but Jack is unwilling or unable to consider the situation from Ma's perspective and realize why Room was not a good place to be.
          If this selfishness is a common trait among children, it again just shows how it is an innate trait independent, or at least less dependent, of environment.  This is the kind of experiment that behavioral scientists would love to be able to perform, but are unable to because of ethical concerns.  On the other hand, if this self-centeredness is more or less unique to Jack, it shows a distinctly unheroic aspect of Jack's character: his either refusal or inability to "walk a mile in the shoes" of another.

2 comments:

  1. As for your comment about Jack's selfishness, it's interesting that his exposure to the world marks the first time that selfishness could even be identified as a problem. In Room, there's what Jack wants to do and what Ma wants to do. Since her main goal is to give him as normal an upbringing as possible, and since virtually anything he could do in Room would contribute to continued development, there are few things Ma would object to, and therefore few times that Ma and Jack would have any conflict. As we saw in the text, it was an abnormality to have three arguments in a short span of time. Once there are hundreds of others in Jack's immediate vicinity, it becomes much more difficult to accommodate everyone's desires. Since Jack has no practice with that, he pretty evidently fails to do so.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think the points you make about Jack's selfishness very interesting, since he seems to think of material possessions as belonging to both he and Ma because of all the things in Room belonged to both of them. However, despite this unselfishness between him and Ma with regard to material things, he is very selfish about things like "having some" and returning to Room at the end.

    ReplyDelete